Labels: Book Reviews, Entertainment, Events
At 7/23/2007 12:18:00 PM, Erin
My husband is a clucker.
I have watched all the movies (that are available on video) myself in order to assess them for my kids and I thought they were great; but my husband trusts Dobson's judgment more than mine. I finally last night convinced him to let our 11 year old watch the movies so we rented Sorcerer's Stone and he loved it.
I know the movies are a different animal than the books. I haven't read the books - bot because I have been avoiding them but I just haven't - I always have too many books on my reading list. But I think I will take that on soon since everyone seems to love them.
John Smulo says the magic in these stories is nowhere near pagan or occult reality (not that I thought it was, but knowing that helped my husband), so I don't know why everyone is so worried. I haven't heard of any instances of Christian kids suddenly becoming witches because of Harry Potter.
At 7/23/2007 12:26:00 PM, Andrew
I understand wanting to talk about it. I don't know anyone around me who has read it yet. I was sooo satisfied at the end. I had this fear that, if ended wrongly, it would taint the other books for me (such as Matrix 3).
The continued message of redemption she wrote about is so powerful. Just amazing.
At 7/23/2007 09:06:00 PM, Julie
These books are so not occultish - they are more in the realm of myth and allegory. I would recommend these books as having more value for living rightly than almost any other "young adult" books (including so called Christian ones) that I have ever encountered.
Karen - I highly agree that Thursday should be a discussion on this. Granted there will be a couple of people in the room who still haven't gotten around to reading book 6 who would kill us... Mike's half way through (did I mention he's a slow reader...). It probably doesn't help that I am constantly asking him where he is at!
At 7/24/2007 06:22:00 AM, Unknown
the books never worked for me either, but then again neither did narnia... LOTR is of course totally different :)
I guess we need to put this into context with our kids, i'd let mine read the books but i'd want to talk with them about what they thought/experienced and relate that to the values of our faith.
saying that in the UK there has been a massive number of enquiries to various pagan/witch organisations off the back of kids reading harry potter and getting a hunger for his experience/adventure, with magic seen as a means to an end of getting that reality.
ultimately as i can see the tale is about good vs evil which is pretty universal in its application...
I'm trying Julie, but I just keep falling asleep -not a reflection on the book or the author, rather I am just sooooooo tired. Plus we had the musical yesterday, tho Carissa and I both took our copies to read while we waited for it to start and at intermission..... :)
The other thing is I just don't wanna rush - it's the LAST book! OK - back to reading..... ;)